For those of us without the benefit of deeper understanding through some form of mind-enhancing substance, it is hard to get the head around all the latest talk about drug control. But let’s try.
Broadly speaking it is all about the prohibition, decriminalisation or legalisation of drugs such as cannabis, heroin and cocaine.
Thirteen years ago,
pioneered the decriminalisation route. It is not without its critics, but it
has been generally acclaimed a success. Portugal
Just to get it straight,
did not legalise, it decriminalised drug use. Portugal
This meant a switch from jailing to treating. Using any illegal drug came to be regarded as an issue for the health authorities rather than the justice department.
While drug use is no longer a criminal offence in
trafficking and dealing still are - and they consumes a lot of police and court
A major new study commissioned by the British Home Office included a comparison between the
UK’s conventional efforts to control users and ’s
decriminalised approach. Portugal
It concluded, inter alia, that the tough punishments dished out in the
do nothing to dissuade people
from using drugs. UK
The Home Office report also stated: ‘‘It is clear that there has not been a lasting and significant increase in drug use in
since 2001.” Portugal
The study’s findings were welcomed by the
coalition government’s Liberal Democrats who are in favour of reform. The
Conservatives were not impressed. A spokesman for Prime Minister David Cameron
said: “We have no intention of decriminalising drugs.” UK
Kathy Gyngell, a research fellow for a right-leaning British think tank, commented: “First the great Portuguese drug decriminalisation fallacy was fostered; now a British liberalisation myth has been strapped on the back of it by a ruthless and conscienceless pro-drugs lobby.”
Harsh words, but then acrimony and recriminations are normal on the highly contentious subject of drug control.
The subject is hazy and much misunderstood because it is complex. It evokes strong emotions, especially among parents. Statistics do not always tell the whole story and can be slanted or used selectively to support squiffy ideas on one side or the other.
Pope Francis told delegates attending a drug conference in
that attempts to legalise recreational drugs “are not only highly questionable
from a legislative standpoint, but fail to produce the desired effects.” Rome
Anti-prohibitionists point to the irony in
where children find it easy to get hold of illegal marijuana but cannot buy
legally regulated alcohol until they are 18. Britain
Reform campaigners claim that far from providing the best protection against drug abuse, locking up ‘soft’ drug users is likely to push them into ‘hard’ drugs. What they need – and what they get in
– is counselling. Portugal
Whatever one thinks of decriminalisation,
has prompted other countries to take note. While Portugal Britain
and countries such as France
and Sweden are sticking to
their guns in the ‘war on drugs,’ Holland, Spain, Italy,
Switzerland, Austria and have all steered away from
strict prohibition. Germany
became the first country to make it legal to grow, consume and sell cannabis.
This summer Uruguay
announced it would decriminalise the possession of small amounts of ‘ganja’ as
cannabis is known there. Jamaica
These developments seem to be building towards a fundamental global shift in attitude, guided not only by social concerns but also by also hard economic realities.
“Criminalising users of heroin, cocaine and cannabis has handed global criminal gangs and terrorists a market worth at least $300 billion a year,” says Baroness Meacher, leader of
All Party Parliamentary Group for Drug Policy Reform. Britain
All eyes will now be on
Uruguay and the states
of Washington and to see if the legalisation of
cannabis, from cultivation to retail outlets, puts the illegal dealers there out
of business. Colorado
If cannabis follows the pattern of the wine and spirits industry, trade will be taken from the criminals and placed in the hands of law-abiding business people who, in the words of the Economist, “pay their taxes and obey rules on where, when and to whom they can sell their products. Money saved on policing weed can be spent on chasing real criminals, or on treatment for addicts.”
may consider it wise to
cut off the flow of money to the crooks by moving from decriminalising drug use
to legalising it in some qualified way. Portugal
The next opportunity for making real progress on a globally coordinated alternative to the hugely costly and hopelessly failing ‘war on drugs’ will come in 2016 at a United Nations General Assembly Special Sessions gathering in New York.
The last such summit was in 2009. The next was scheduled for 2019 but has been brought forward, so there is more than a hint of urgency in seeking some pragmatic form of global ‘peace.’